Sunday, October 5, 2008

We can prosper in Peace, not in Hatered

From Greater Kashmir (Also read Behind the Scenes)
So far the state of J&K was immune from communal onslaughts after the massacre of 1947. The people of these two regions were sharing good and bad days with each other like brothers. Many more ugly events took place in other states of the country since partition but it did not affect the harmony. But unfortunately the Amarnath Land Row created abrupt wedge between these two partners and created so much distance between them which seems very difficult now to bridge. Kashmiris fully know that the people of Jammu are tolerant race and have seen many ups and downs during last sixty years but have never reacted in such a harsh way against other sects of the state. This time they have entirely forgotten the past sixty years close association with their state mates of Kashmir and have used drastic and unlawful measures against them which were beyond expectation. Thus the Kashmiri Muslims and the Muslims of surrounding areas of Jammu had to sustain irreparable loss of precious lives and huge property and have become unwanted within a short burst of time. They have crossed all the limits and have not even hesitated to block the National Highway leading to Kashmir from Lakhanpur and stopped flow of essential supplies to Kashmir for days together. Wherever they spotted any loaded truck with goods bound for Kashmir, they got hold of the drivers and beat them to the pulp and hurled petrol bombs on them which made them half dead during the course of travelling. After words two drivers of Kashmir breathed their last in Srinagar. These harsh steps are taken at the last stage in the battlefield when all logic fails to work and when the two sides are to part company from each other for good. Therefore it appears that the Sangrash Committee may have some other aims in their heart of hearts, as such the land row seems a mere beginning. These agitating rioters gave communal color to the crusade launched against the Muslims at the behest of Sang Parivar, thereby crossed all the limits of humanity. In spite of such a big upheaval against a particular sect, the authorities at the corridors of power took it very lightly, thereby giving more time to goons of the fascist forces to continue their deplorable acts against the Muslims. The saddest part of the agitation was that the Kashmiri Pandits affiliated with so called “Panun Kashmir” and “Kashmir Samiti’, spewing venom against Kashmiri Muslims and the Muslims of surrounding areas of Jammu. They are the persons who used iron rods, chains, tridents and petrol bombs against Muslims and hurt their religious sentiments in a very crude manner. This they are doing contrary to the sincere efforts of Kashmiri Muslims for their homecoming. The wounds inflicted upon the said community during the upheaval may heal up in due course but the scars of the wounds will remain visible for all times to come and may revive the scuffle if the demands of the Sangrash Committee are beyond Amarnath. Thus the communal divide has turned the two communities poles apart. Now the land row agitation has come to halt in the wake of a recent accord reached between the Government and the Sangrash Committee on 31st August 2008. But it is one sided. Therefore it would be ever lasting and credible agreement only when Kashmiri Pandiths will take up the management of the Yatra.
S M Qadiri

"what is sad is that the focus in kashmir, especially of the Pundit community is not on the human shade of the dispute but on the geographical side. they want thier land back, the land which they were forced leave, but they refuse to see that this land also belongs to the common kashmiri who has spent a lifetime in a troubled land, who has seen his family die at the hands of the militants as well as of the army"- Anonymous, on Planforindia

3 comments:

Unknown said...

"Kashmiris fully know that the people of Jammu are tolerant race and have seen many ups and downs during last sixty years but have never reacted in such a harsh way against other sects of the state."

Unfortunately, the pandits were too tolerant. They had to pay the price for their tolerance by staying in the most unsanitized conditions as refugees in their own country.

Anonymous said...

Dear Sachin, I firmly believe that we must not accept or reject anything on the face of it without searching for causes/reasons/facts and only after we are thoroughly convinced should we form an opinion.

I appreciate that you wrote whatever you had in mind.

Some food for thought:

1. More than 100,000 Kashmiri Muslims have been killed over the past 20 years in Kashmir. You might be aware that many Muslims also fled the valley during the initial years due to fear. However, they never sold their property thus leaving the return option open.

2. As per official estimates of Govt of India, less than a hundred Kashmiri Pandits were killed during militancy. Still our KP brothers prefer to call it "genocide". Why they left the valley is another theory which may or may not be correct. But if we analyse the facts, the theory appears to be correct.

3. Why did Sikhs never leave the valley in spite of most dreaded massacre of Sikhs at Chhati Singhpora where about 40 Sikhs were killed in a single day (half the number of total KPs killed till date)

4. The fact of the matter remains that they didnt pay a price for their tolerance, but for their trust an belief in Jagmohan, whose miscalculations resulted in KPs paying the price.

Think over it.

Anonymous said...

hi there,
great to hear you acknowledge the tolerant ,peace loving people of jammu,(wish i could reciprocate the compliment,but am afraid can,t do that,and bet you know more than why!!).
One thing that is intriguing more than anything is the stand of the Kashmiris.What is it that you want?Is it Azadi that you desire ,or is it something else.Is the idea of Indianness too hard to be congruent with, what is it? From the look of it ,seems like you people don't gel with the indian thing, but then there are certain amiguities attached to it.If the idea of identifying as an indian is that below dignity for a kashmiri ,then how come the financial aid, the development projects, the professional degrees, the trade, the business ventures all across the nation, aren't!!
Why don't you guys boycott everything that is indian (and not just the army there !!),only that would clear your stand (if there is one!!)
Every ethnicity has perhaps got a right to express be it the kashmiri muslims, the kashmiri hindus, the dogras, the ladakhis ,every one, but then may be it has to be a little more than these anachronistic slogans of azadi which are so damn heretical especially when they get contradicted by the things mentioned above.